Merchant of Record vs Payment Facilitator vs Stripe Connect (2025 Guide for Creators)
Key takeaway (read this first):
If you want one entity to swallow all tax, charge-back and PCI headaches, a Merchant of Record (MoR) such as Paddle or FastSpring is still the lowest-friction path in 2025—but you’ll pay 5-10 % of every sale for the privilege. A Payment Facilitator (PayFac) gives you more control and marginally lower fees, yet you inherit marketplace-facilitator tax rules and must clear tough PCI DSS 4.0 checks. Stripe Connect sits in the middle: the platform retains brand control and sets its own pricing, but creators remain on the hook for disputes and some compliance duties. Choose MoR when speed and global tax coverage matter most; choose PayFac or Stripe Connect when brand ownership, data control, and multi-seller flexibility outweigh extra compliance lift.
TL;DR comparison
What each model really means
Merchant of Record (MoR)
A Merchant of Record is a reseller that buys your product wholesale, then sells it to the end customer and shoulders payment processing, taxes, chargebacks, and card-network fines. That makes the MoR the legal seller on every invoice and card statement.
Creator upside: zero tax filings, instant PCI compliance, single wire payout each month.
Creator trade-off: less brand control, MoR sets FX rates, and you must accept their refund policy.
Payment Facilitator (PayFac)
A PayFac registers with Visa/Mastercard, underwrites each “sub-merchant” (your creators), and aggregates all transactions under its master MID. This lowers onboarding friction compared with a traditional acquirer, but the sub-merchant still owns tax liability and must appear on customer statements.
2025 watch-out: PCI DSS 4.0 requires PayFacs to prove client-side security by 31 March 2025, adding dev work for smaller platforms.
Stripe Connect
Stripe Connect gives platforms three flavours (Standard, Express, Custom). With Standard accounts, Stripe underwrites the creator directly; with Custom, the platform handles KYC and bears more liability. Fees start at 2.9 % + 30 ¢ but platforms can layer their own margin.
Key clause: even with Standard, the connected creator is “financially liable to Stripe for the full amount of all disputes.”
Costs & fee structures in 2025
- MoR: Paddle advertises 5 % + 50 ¢ per transaction, including all taxes and FX; FastSpring ranges 8–10 % for high-risk verticals.
- PayFac: PayFac-as-a-Service vendors (e.g., Finix, Stripe PFaaS) quote 2.75-3.25 % + 30 ¢ plus 10–30 bp for facilitation. Industry analysts project PayFacs will collect $15 b in net rev by 2025.
- Stripe Connect: Base U.S. rate 2.9 % + 30 ¢; add 0.5 % for instant payouts, 1 % cross-border, and 0.4 % for tax calculation (Stripe Tax).
Liability & compliance checklist
Pros & cons for creators selling digital products
Merchant of Record
Pros
- One contract and dashboard—ideal for non-technical solo entrepreneurs.
- Global tax compliance (EU VAT OSS, U.K. HMRC, U.S. marketplace-facilitator rules) baked in.
Cons
- Higher total take-rate versus other models.
- MoR name appears on customer card statements, diluting brand.
Payment Facilitator
Pros
- Keep brand on receipts; faster sub-merchant onboarding than full acquirer model.
- Easier to layer value-added services (loyalty, installments).
Cons
- Must integrate KYC flows and maintain sponsor-bank relationship.
- Creators still chase chargebacks and file taxes.
Stripe Connect
Pros
- Flexible account types and country support; instant payout options.
- Custom pricing lets platform monetise volume.
Cons
- Dispute liability sits with creator; high-risk categories may be shut down without notice (see Reddit cases).
- Stripe Tax is optional—compliance burden may persist.
2025 trends that change the calculus
- PCI DSS 4.0 enforcement extends scope to client-side scripts—PayFacs must invest in CSP and monitoring or face fines.
- PFaaS growth: Mastercard predicts PayFac-as-a-Service will halve go-live times for ISVs by late 2025.
- Marketplace-facilitator laws now cover digital goods in 46 U.S. states; creators acting as their own merchant must file or face audit.
- Global VAT reforms: OECD’s 2025 e-commerce package pushes liability up the supply chain—favouring MoR models.
Implementation checklist
- Map liabilities: list who eats chargebacks, refunds, VAT for each jurisdiction.
- Model fees vs. LTV: a 5 % MoR fee may be cheaper than a 3 % PayFac fee once you add VAT filing software and PCI audits.
- Test K-factor: compare onboarding conversion rates for MoR checkout vs. Stripe Connect OAuth.
- Review contracts annually: card-network rulebooks and state nexus thresholds change every January.
Frequently asked questions
Does a Merchant of Record cover Canadian GST/HST for me?
Yes. Major MoRs file GST/HST and QST on your behalf, then remit net revenue to you.
Can I switch from Stripe Connect to a PayFac later?
You can, but you’ll need to re-KYC every creator and migrate tokens—budget four weeks of engineering.
Does Stripe automatically file U.S. sales tax?
Not by default; you must enable Stripe Tax at 0.5 % of transaction volume.
What happens if a creator exceeds $100k in a sales-tax nexus state?
Under marketplace-facilitator laws the platform must start collecting and remitting tax the next filing period.
Will PCI DSS 4.0 affect small creators?
If you use a fully hosted MoR checkout, you remain out of scope. PayFac and Stripe Connect users must at least complete SAQ A by 31 Mar 2025.
Conclusion: Choosing Your 2025 Payment Stack
There’s no single “best” model—only the one that balances control, cost, and compliance for your stage of growth. If you need to ship globally tomorrow and never touch a tax return, a Merchant of Record keeps you safely out of scope for VAT, PCI-DSS, and chargebacks—at the price of a 5-10 % take-rate. Paddle
Creators with engineering muscle and thousands of sub-accounts may squeeze margins with a Payment Facilitator or the emerging PayFac-as-a-Service model, but they’ll inherit marketplace-facilitator tax rules and the new PCI 4.0 audit burden in March 2025. MastercardWareIQ
Platforms that want fine-grained branding and payout logic without full PayFac overhead can still thrive on Stripe Connect—just remember that every connected account remains “financially liable to Stripe for the full amount of all disputes.” Stripe
Bottom line: run the numbers on fees and hidden compliance costs, map who owns liability in each jurisdiction, and pick the path that scales with your audience. Rally.Fan’s own checkout stack is engineered around these trade-offs—so when you’re ready to monetize without the paperwork nightmare, we’ll help you plug in the model that fits and keep you selling.
.png)
